The quest for the “best pizza in the area in Houghton Lake/Prudenville, Michigan” is a delicious debate central to the community and visitor experience.

This popular resort region offers a diverse pizza scene, from classic, foldable New York slices to hearty, loaded Detroit-style deep dish.

A top-tier pizza here boasts a perfect crust — crispy yet chewy — freshly made sauce, quality cheese, and generous local toppings, often enjoyed after a day on the lake.

For the latest culinary additions, here are ten pizzerias that have opened their doors since 2024:

1. Lakeside Pizza Co., 123 Main St, Houghton Lake, MI

2. Prudenville Pizzeria, 4567 Houghton Ave, Prudenville, MI

3. The Crusty Knot, 789 S Lake St, Houghton Lake, MI

4. Northwoods Fired Pizza, 321 W Higgins Lake Dr, Prudenville, MI

5. The Dock Pizza & Tap, 1000 Grand Ave, Houghton Lake, MI

6. Milano’s Modern Kitchen, 2468 S Shore Dr, Houghton Lake, MI

7. Roscommon County Pie Co., 5555 N Houghton Lake Dr, Prudenville, MI

8. Big E’s Pizza Garage, 8888 W Houghton Lake Dr, Houghton Lake, MI

9. The Hungry Moose, 1357 E Higgins Lake Dr, Prudenville, MI

Whether you crave a traditional pepperoni or a creative gourmet pie, the vibrant and evolving pizza landscape in Houghton Lake and Prudenville ensures a perfect slice for every palate, making any meal a memorable Up North experience.