Top 5 Milwaukee Spots for Beef Stroganoff or Beef Tips

1. Five O’Clock Steakhouse

2416 W State St, Milwaukee, WI 53233

A revered Milwaukee supper‑club since 1946, Five O’Clock occasionally features a beef stroganoff special: an 8 oz tenderloin served over fettuccine with julienned beets, pickles and sour cream  Known for steaks and live music, it’s a full experience.

2. Eddie Martini’s (Wauwatosa)

8612 W Watertown Plank Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53226

Wauwatosa’s elegant steakhouse offers a beef short‑rib stroganoff on the lunch menu — slow‑braised beef, cognac sauce over pasta — that’s earned rave reviews.

3. Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club (Wauwatosa)

7700 Harwood Ave, Wauwatosa, WI 53213

This northwoods‑inspired supper club is a local favorite for mushroom stroganoff among other supper‑club classics, praised for atmosphere and solid stroganoff portions.

4. Joey Gerard’s – A Bartolotta Supper Club

Mequon/Broad St suburbs of Milwaukee
Part of the Bartolotta family supper clubs, Joey Gerard’s lists beef stroganoff as a rotating daily special; reviewers mention diners enjoying the stroganoff “daily special” paired with rib eye or filet.

5. The Packing House (Mitchell Field area)

3736 W Mitchell St, Milwaukee, WI 53218

While known as a steakhouse near the airport, Yelp reviewers highlight their beef stroganoff special with perfect beef and mushroom pastry accompaniment.

Why These Stand Out

• Beef‑centric menus with stroganoff or braised‑beef variants

• Distinct environments: from classic supper clubs to northwoods rustic or upscale dining

• Strong reputations across local reviews, Yelp, and Reddit communities

Whether you’re chasing a traditional stroganoff or short‑rib riffs over noodles, these five places in Milwaukee and Wauwatosa deliver — with unique settings, rich sauces, and dependable quality.