Kick off your 2026 with the ultimate comfort food by indulging in authentic, slow-simmered oxtail.

If you are searching for where to buy oxtail that features that signature “fall-off-the-bone” texture and rich, savory gravy, Salem County’s independent culinary scene has you covered.

Avoid the mass-produced flavors of big franchises; instead, order from local kitchens that prioritize traditional recipes and fresh ingredients.

Whether you want to book a table for New Year’s Day or order oxtail delivery for a cozy holiday at home, these non-chain gems offer the best value for your cravings.

From Caribbean-inspired jerk oxtail to soulful, southern-style braised cuts, the “buy local” experience ensures a high-quality meal that supports your community.

Check out the menus below and secure your savory feast before they sell out—these popular local platters are in high demand!

  1. Nellie’s Food Lounge: 154 West Broadway, Salem, NJ 08079

  2. Diamond Grill: 534 Salem Quinton Rd, Salem, NJ 08079

  3. El Paladar Boricua: 161 Broadway Rd, Salem, NJ 08079

  4. Big Boy Deli: 49 Broadway Rd, Salem, NJ 08079

  5. Green Olive Restaurant: 610 Route 40, Pilesgrove, NJ 08098

  6. Italian Kitchen: 339 N Hook Rd, Pennsville, NJ 0807

  7. Nine Thai Kitchen 2: 233 S Broadway, Pennsville, NJ 08070

  8. Sang Tong Thai: 233 S Broadway, Pennsville, NJ 08070

  9. ZZ Sushi Kitchen: 233 S Broadway, Pennsville, NJ 08070

  10. Woodstown Diner: 16 East Ave, Woodstown, NJ 08098

  11. Richman’s Restaurant: 849 Route 40, Pilesgrove, NJ 08098

  12. Kountry Kitchen Restaurant: 373 Harding Hwy, Pittsgrove, NJ 08318

  13. Elmer Diner: 491 S Harding Hwy, Elmer, NJ 08318

  14. Dodge’s Market: 55 N Main St, Elmer, NJ 08318

  15. In and Out Kitchen: 100 S Broadway, Pennsville, NJ 08070

  16. Giza Caribbean Cuisine: 1576 Mount Ephraim Ave, Camden, NJ 08104

  17. Sun Island Bar-BQ & Jerk: 1200 S White Horse Pike, Somerdale, NJ 08083

  18. Cowtown Restaurant: 780 Harding Hwy, Pilesgrove, NJ 08098

  19. Chow’s Garden: 110 S Broadway, Pennsville, NJ 08070

  20. Roman’s Pizza: 102 N Broadway, Pennsville, NJ 08070

Choosing a local, non-chain restaurant ensures you receive a hand-crafted New Year’s meal that celebrates the unique culinary culture of Salem County.

These 30 independent businesses provide the best transactional opportunities for diners seeking quality, authenticity, and premium oxtail dishes.