Here are two standout spots on Long Island where you can find gooey cinnamon rolls:

Glenn Wayne Bakery (Bohemia)
1800 Arctic Ave, Bohemia, NY 11716

A beloved wholesale bakery that’s been turning out soft, pillowy rolls for over three decades.

Known locally for their fresh‑baked donuts and buns, including cinnamon rolls with that perfect balance of sticky-sweetness.

Hometown Bakeshop (Centerport)
2 Little Neck Rd, Centerport, NY 11721.

This cozy, family-run bake shop boasts “ginormous” cinnamon rolls packed with gooey centers and generous icing — big enough to share.

Their sweets are a local favorite!

While Long Island has many bakeries, these two are particularly celebrated online for buttery, soft, gooey buns that hit all the right notes.

If you’re exploring other nearby towns — like Garden City, Huntington, or Smithtown — it might be worth a quick Yelp search for gooey cinnamon treats there as well.