For seafood lovers, there’s nothing quite like biting into a hot, buttery lobster roll. Peekskill, New York, while known for its scenic views and cultural charm, also happens to be close to some fantastic lobster roll spots.

If you’ve tried the lobster roll at Ossining’s Boathouse and it didn’t hit the mark, don’t worry! There are plenty of other places in and around Peekskill where you can find delicious, hot lobster rolls.

Here are the top five places within a reasonable distance to get your lobster fix.

1. The Twisted Oak – Tarrytown, NY

Just a short drive from Peekskill, The Twisted Oak in Tarrytown offers a high-quality dining experience with its hot lobster roll as one of the stars.

Served with freshly caught lobster, lightly buttered and toasted rolls, and a sprinkle of herbs, it’s a must-try for seafood lovers.

The Twisted Oak is known for using fresh, locally sourced ingredients, which makes all the difference in the flavor.

Location: 61 Main St, Tarrytown, NY 10591
Why it stands out: Fresh, local ingredients and a perfectly toasted roll.

2. North River Lobster Company – NYC (Hudson River)

If you’re up for a bit of a drive into the city, the North River Lobster Company is a floating lobster shack that offers both an incredible lobster roll and a unique dining experience on a boat cruising the Hudson River.

Their hot lobster roll is a traditional New England-style delight, served with a side of river views. It’s worth the trip for both the lobster and the scenic experience.

Location: Pier 81 W 41st St, New York, NY 10036
Why it stands out: A one-of-a-kind floating seafood shack on the Hudson River.

3. City Island Lobster House – City Island, NY

City Island Lobster House is a bit farther, but if you’re craving a hot lobster roll packed with flavor, this spot in City Island is worth the visit.

Their lobster rolls are filled with chunky, buttery lobster meat and served on a perfectly toasted roll. Plus, their casual, laid-back atmosphere makes it a great place to relax and enjoy some seafood.

Location: 691 Bridge St, City Island, NY 10464
Why it stands out: Generous portions of lobster meat and a casual, seaside vibe.

4. Saltaire Oyster Bar – Port Chester, NY

Located in nearby Port Chester, Saltaire Oyster Bar specializes in seafood, and their lobster roll is no exception.

Served hot with drawn butter and a toasted bun, this roll is a simple yet perfect rendition of a classic lobster roll.

The restaurant also boasts a beautiful waterfront location, making it a great spot for a date or special occasion.

Location: 55 Abendroth Ave, Port Chester, NY 10573
Why it stands out: A beautifully crafted lobster roll in an upscale, waterfront setting.

5. LobsterCraft – Greenwich, CT

Just over the border in Connecticut, LobsterCraft in Greenwich offers one of the best lobster rolls in the area.

Known for its fresh lobster and toasted, buttery buns, LobsterCraft has earned a loyal following.

They focus on delivering a traditional New England-style hot lobster roll, with the lobster lightly seasoned to let the natural flavors shine through.

Location: 107 Greenwich Ave, Greenwich, CT 06830
Why it stands out: Consistently high-quality lobster rolls with a focus on simple, fresh ingredients.

Conclusion

Finding the perfect hot lobster roll near Peekskill, New York is easier than you might think. From the upscale offerings at The Twisted Oak to the unique experience at North River Lobster Company, each of these locations delivers a mouthwatering lobster roll worth the trip.

Whether you prefer a casual seaside vibe or a more upscale dining experience, these five spots are sure to satisfy your lobster cravings.

So the next time you’re in the mood for a lobster roll, head to one of these restaurants, and be sure to enjoy every delicious bite!